For Ellem, the road to motherhood has been anything but easy. After a high-risk pregnancy, she’s about to welcome her first child and already thinking about the future – graduate school, her career, and eventually, a second baby. But there’s one thing weighing heavily on her mind: contraception.
“I’m super paranoid,” she admits. “Every option seems to have side effects, and I’m not sure what’s safe or reliable.’”
Navigating the world of contraceptives can feel overwhelming, especially when weighing the risks and benefits of each option. Yet, understanding your choices is so important. It’s time to take control of your reproductive health and make the decisions that best suit your needs – and those of your partner.
What is Contraception?
Contraception, or birth control, refers to methods used to prevent pregnancy. Without contraception, couples who engage in regular sexual activity have an 84% chance of conceiving within a year.
In Singapore, the rise in unplanned pregnancies highlights the importance of accessible birth control. A study by SingHealth Polyclinics (SHP) found a 60% increase in referrals for abortions between 2018 and 2020, with most referrals involving single women under 20 or over 40.
According to Dr Ryan Lee, Consultant Obstetrician and Gynaecologist, the key contributors to unplanned pregnancies include:
- Inadequate knowledge of contraception
- Lack of sexual education
- Limited access to personalised family planning services
With a variety of contraceptive options available today, it’s more important than ever to understand the different types, benefits and limitations, so you can choose the most suitable method for your needs.
How Do Contraceptives Work?
Contraceptives can be broadly classified into hormonal, barrier, permanent, natural, and emergency methods. Each birth control method works in their own unique ways to prevent pregnancy if used correctly.
- Barrier methods physically block the sperm from reaching the egg.
- Hormonal methods suppresses ovulation, thickens the mucus to hinder sperms movement, and alter the uterine lining.
- Permanent methods involve removal of parts of reproductive organs through surgery.
- Natural methods involves tracking ovulation, abstinence during fertile periods and withdrawal before ejaculation.
- Emergency methods delay the release of egg from the ovaries after unprotected intercourse
Contraceptive Options for Females
Barrier Methods
Diaphragm or Cervical Cap
Diaphragms and cervical caps are silicone cups inserted into the vagina to cover the cervix snugly. This blocks the passage of sperm from entering the uterus.
They can be inserted prior to sex, and left inside the body for hours after sex to ensure the sperm have time to die and cannot enter the uterus.
Effectiveness: 83% effectiveness (typical use)
Pros: The silicone cups are reusable.
Drawbacks: Insertion and removal of diaphragms or cervical caps may require fitting by a healthcare provider.
Female Condoms
The female condom has two ends: the closed inner end and the open outer end. In between the two ends is a sleeve that lines the vagina. You can insert it like you would a tampon or menstrual cup, until the inner end sits comfortably near the cervix. The outer open ring should stay outside the vagina.
Effectiveness: 79% effectiveness (typical use)
Pros: Female condoms may protect against sexually transmitted infections (STIs).
Drawbacks: They are less readily available compared to male condoms.
Spermicides
Spermicides are chemicals (often nonoxynol-9) in gel, cream or suppository forms. They are applied to the vagina to damage the sperm. It can be combined with other barrier contraceptives like condoms, cervical caps and diaphragms to enhance the effectiveness.
Effectiveness: Spermicides are only about 70% effective when used alone.
Pros: Spermicides are easy to use.
Drawbacks: Spermicides need to be applied before each sexual intercourse, and the window of effectiveness differs from product to product. They also increase the risk of infection as spermicides can irritate the vaginal tissue.
Hormonal Methods
Oral Contraceptive Pills (OCPs)
Oral contraceptive pills can be divided into two types:
- Combination pill contains both oestrogen and progesterone.
- Progestogen-only pills contain progesterone only. They are suitable for breastfeeding women or those who cannot take oestrogen.
“Side effects such as headache, nausea, spotting and breast tenderness will stabilise within three months of OCPs initiation.” shared Dr Genevieve Quek, general practitioner at Clinic10, Singapore.
It is common and often preferable for ladies to start OCPs at the lowest dose of hormones. This helps to reduce the risk of side effects and to assess he suitability of treatment. There are many brands of OCPs available in the market, and you can have a discussion with your doctor about the different brands and options available to you.
Effectiveness: OCPs are 93% effective (typical use) and 99% effective (perfect use)
Pros: Besides contraception, OCPs can help to regulate menstrual cycles, relieve painful periods, and manage hormonal acne.
Drawbacks:
- OCPs require daily compliance as missed doses will reduce the efficacy.
- As a hormonal contraceptive, OCPs may cause side effects such as headaches, nausea, mood changes and breast tenderness.
- OCPs may increase the risk of blood clots. They are unsuitable for individuals with history of stroke or heart issues.
- It does not protect against sexually transmitted infections.
Contraceptive Patch
Contraceptive patch delivers the hormones oestrogen and progesterone into the skin through dermal absorption.
Effectiveness: The patch is about 91-94% effective.
Pros: Contraceptive patch allows better adherence with weekly application.
Drawbacks:
- As a hormonal contraceptive, the birth control patch can cause similar side effects as OCPs.
- If the patch becomes partially or completely detached for over 24 hours, you will need to apply a new patch and use a backup method of contraception for one week to prevent pregnancies.
- It does not protect against sexually transmitted infections.
Contraceptive Implant
The contraceptive implant is place under the skin of the upper arm via a simple in-clinic procedure. The implanted rod releases a low, steady dose of hormones, and it can last for three years.
Effectiveness: 99% effectiveness
Pros: The implants are convenient, and fertility can be restored after removal.
Drawbacks:
- As a hormonal contraceptive, the birth control patch can cause similar side effects as OCPs.
- The contraceptive implants can only be inserted and removed by a healthcare professional.
- It does not protect against sexually transmitted infections.
Contraceptive Injection
The contraceptive injection contains the hormone progestin, which helps to prevent pregnancy. It is injected into your arm or buttock as an intramuscular injection, and remains effective for approximately 12 weeks. You should schedule an appointment every three months for follow-up injections to maintain contraceptive efficacy.
Effectiveness: Each injection is more than 99% effective and lasts for approximately 12 weeks. The effectiveness is reduced if the injection is delayed.
Pros: The contraceptive injection can reduce symptoms such as heavy menses. You also do not have to remember to take it daily or during sex.
Drawbacks:
- As a hormonal contraceptive, the birth control patch can cause similar side effects as OCPs.
- You need to visit your healthcare professional regularly to receive the injections.
- It does not protect against sexually transmitted infections.
- Fertility will take time to be restored after cessation of injections.
Intrauterine Device (IUD)
The IUD works by modifying the uterine environment. It creates conditions that are less favourable for both fertilisation and implantation. To that end, there are two types of IUDs – hormonal and copper IUDs.
Hormonal IUDs release the hormone progesterone into the uterus. Different brands of hormonal IUDs may last for different lengths of time. Copper IUDs, on the other hand, release copper into the uterus and does not contain hormones.
Effectiveness: IUDs are over 99% effective at preventing pregnancies.
Pros: IUDs are very convenient and provide long-term contraception. Fertility is also restored immediately after IUDs removal. There are options for non-hormonal options for those who cannot tolerate hormonal contraception.
Drawbacks:
- IUDs insertion and removal require a healthcare professional.
- IUDs insertion may be uncomfortable for some.
- It does not protect against sexually transmitted infections.
Permanent Contraception
Tubal Ligation
Tubal ligation is a surgical procedure that blocks the fallopian tubes.
Effectiveness: Tubal ligation is almost 100% effective.
Pros: This surgery is permanent. It does not impact hormone levels, and will not affect the menstrual cycle or impact sexual function.
Drawbacks:
- Tubal ligation involves surgery and surgical risks.
- It does not protect against sexually transmitted infections.
- There is a risk of ectopic pregnancy in the rare but possible instance of failure.
Natural Method
Fertility Awareness Methods (FAMs)
FAMs involve tracking ovulation and avoiding intercourse during fertile periods. The monitoring includes:
- Thickness of cervical mucus: Watery, slippery and clear discharge means fertile.
- Calendar method: Strict charting of menstrual cycle and predicting the ovulating days.
- Basal body temperature: Ovulation will cause the body temperature to increase slightly about less than a degree.
Effectiveness: FAMs are only 76-88% effective.
Pros: FAMs are natural and have no side effects. It may fit with faith-based and cultural vales.
Drawbacks:
- FAMs require meticulous tracking and discipline.
- FAMs have a relatively high failure rate compared to other contraceptive methods.
- Natural methods may not be reliable for those with inconsistent menstrual cycles.
- It does not protect against sexually transmitted infections.
Withdrawal (Pull-out) Method
The pull-out method involves your partner pulling their penis from your vagina before they ejaculate.
Effectiveness: 78% effectiveness with typical use. It can be combined with other forms of contraception to enhance the effectiveness.
Pros: The withdrawal method is natural and have no side effects. It also preserves the spontaneity of sex.
Drawbacks:
- It requires self-control for both partners.
- Some sperm may still leave the penis before withdrawal, which makes the method even less effective.
Emergency Contraceptives
Emergency contraceptive pills, or also commonly known as the Morning-After Pill or Plan B, prevent pregnancy after unprotected intercourse. They could be one or two-tablet regime.
Types of Morning-After Pills:
- Levonorgestrel, which needs to be taken within 72 hours after unprotected intercourse
- Ulipristal acetate, which needs to be taken within 120 hours after unprotected intercourse
Effectiveness: Emergency pills are only 85% effective at reducing risk of pregnancy if taken within the window period.
Pros: Morning-after pills are useful for emergencies after unprotected intercourse.
Drawbacks: Emergency pills are less effective compared to daily birth control pills.
If you do not get menses within three weeks of taking emergency contraception, or if you have any symptoms of pregnancy, there is a chance that the medication did not work. Take a pregnancy test or schedule an appointment with your doctor.
Choosing the Right Method
The ideal contraceptive choice depends on several factors. Ask yourself:
- How reliable is this method in preventing pregnancy?
- Do I have any medical conditions that may impact my contraceptive choice?
- Am I planning for future pregnancies, in the near future or otherwise?
- Do I need additional protection for sexually transmitted infections?
- Is it convenient and manageable for my lifestyle?
Finding the perfect birth control method is like choosing a pair of shoes—it has to fit your needs and lifestyle. Do not hesitate to consult a healthcare professional for personalised advice, especially if you have medical conditions for consideration.
Any questions about contraceptives?
Medical Channel Asia has launched a community forum page where you can get questions answered by a medical specialist. Why not ask them at our community forum here.