Intermittent fasting may benefit adolescents with obesity, reducing BMI and improving mental health, as recent studies suggest.
Over the years, many have achieved their weight loss goals, improved their relationship with food, and felt great while following intermittent fasting. Intermittent fasting is characterised by methods such as the 16/8 hours method, and is not inherently a calorie-restrictive diet. In fact, it does not tell you to eat less, just less often.
Intermittent fasting has a variety of studied benefits such as improved insulin sensitivity, balanced cortisol levels, better muscle mass retention than calorie restriction, and increased gut cleaning with the Migrating Motor Complex.
Read also: Intermittent Fasting: Weighing Health Benefits Against Potential Cardiovascular Concerns
These benefits often translate to weight loss, improved gut health, increased energy levels, and decreased bloating. However, is intermittent fasting right for teenagers?
Studies on Intermittent Fasting in Adolescents
A recent 52-week randomised clinical trial conducted at two paediatric centres in Australia involved 141 adolescents aged 13-17 years with obesity and at least one associated complication. This study compared Intermittent Energy Restriction (IER) and Continuous Energy Restriction (CER) in these adolescents.
Study Design
Participants were divided into two groups: IER and CER, with three phases::
- Initial Phase (Weeks 0-4): All participants followed a very low-energy diet of 800 kcal/day using meal replacement products.
- Intensive Intervention (Weeks 5-16): The IER group consumed 600-700 kcal on three non-consecutive days per week, interspersed with days of healthy eating without specific calorie restrictions. The CER group adhered to a daily calorie intake adjusted for age—1430-1670 kcal for those aged 13-14 and 1670-1900 kcal for participants aged 15-17.
- Continued Intervention/Maintenance (Weeks 17-52): The dietary patterns established in Phase 2 continued, with adjustments for those who achieved their goal weight, transitioning them to a maintenance diet.
Findings
The clinical trial revealed several key outcomes:
- BMI Reduction: Both the IER and CER groups showed a reduction of 0.28 in BMI z-scores at 52 weeks, with no significant differences between the groups in terms of body composition or cardiometabolic outcomes.
- Reduced Insulin Resistance: There was a noted reduction in the occurrence of insulin resistance in both groups at week 16, but this effect was maintained only in the CER group at week 52.
- Cardiometabolic Health: There were no significant differences in the occurrence of dyslipidemia or impaired hepatic function between the groups.
A secondary analysis of the trial revealed important findings about psychological symptoms:
- Initial Symptoms: At the start, scores indicated moderate levels of eating disorder symptoms, depression, and binge eating among participants.
- Improvements Maintained: By the end of the study, both the IER and CER groups had maintained early improvements in depression and eating disorder symptoms.
- Binge Eating: Only the IER group continued to see a reduction in binge eating.
- Need for Support: About 12% of the adolescents required additional support for depression or disordered eating during the trial, including some who developed new or worsening symptoms.
Clinical Implications
Dr. Lister, author in both studies of the same trial, explained the significance of these findings.
“Many adolescents were presenting to our hospital weight management clinics already following this diet or wanting to try this, yet there had not been any research to inform safety and effectiveness. In Australia, there are few treatment options for adolescents with obesity, which is associated with poorer immediate and long-term physical and mental health and well-being.”
These findings suggest that for adolescents with obesity-related complications, IER can be incorporated into a behavioural weight management program. This provides an option in addition to CER and offering more choice to patients and families.
Considerations for Teens and Fasting
Despite the findings, there are several considerations to take into account before recommending intermittent fasting for teenagers:
- Growth and Development: Adolescents are in a critical period of growth and development. Nutritional needs are higher during this stage to support growth, hormonal changes, and cognitive development.
- Psychological Impact: Restrictive eating patterns can potentially lead to an unhealthy relationship with food or disordered eating behaviours, especially in vulnerable populations like teenagers.
- Social and Family Life: Meal times are not just for nutrition but are also important for social interactions and family bonding, which could be affected by fasting.
Key Takeaway
While intermittent fasting may offer a structured path to addressing obesity in adolescents, it should be approached with caution. Parents and guardians should consult with healthcare professionals to ensure that any diet plan, including intermittent fasting, is appropriate for their teenager’s individual health needs and life stage. As always, a balanced diet, regular physical activity, and sufficient sleep are crucial for the healthy development of teenagers.
References
- Lister, N. B., Baur, L. A., House, E. T., et al. (2024). Intermittent energy restriction for adolescents with obesity: The Fast Track to Health randomized clinical trial. JAMA Pediatrics. Advance online publication. https://doi.org/10.1001/jamapediatrics.2024.2869
- Bakhsh, J. A., Vidmar, A. P., & Salvy, S. J. (2024). Intermittent fasting in youth: A scoping review. Research Square. [Preprint]. https://doi.org/10.21203/rs.3.rs-4524102/v1
- Jebeile, H., Baur, L. A., Kwok, C., et al. (2024). Symptoms of depression, eating disorders, and binge eating in adolescents with obesity: The Fast Track to Health randomized clinical trial. JAMA Pediatrics. Advance online publication. https://doi.org/10.1001/jamapediatrics.2024.2851
